One more attempt at a rule of thumb definition for how to spot an Evangelical (the noun, not the adjective):
Evangelicals are (a) leveling, (b) faith-alone, (c) socially conservative (d) inerrantist (e) biblicists who (f) care about conversion, (g) don’t baptize babies, and (h) assume ecclesial pluralism.
Even if we follow Bonnie with a center and periphery, I think something like these characteristics—more than the Beggington quadrilateral or variations on it—define the center, with objections and demurrals placing one ever closer to the periphery or beyond it.
The only question for me, given this definition, is whether (actual, true) fundamentalists would belong at the center or whether a further characteristic would need to be added to exclude them. It seems to me that fundies and ‘jellies’ are joined at the hip, locked in perpetual embrace and conflict, so excluding them out by definition is question-begging. But your mileage may vary.