Randy Boyagoda takes down Chad Harbach and anyone even half-admiring his new novel.
I thought this write-up of “a weekend with sex-realist feminists” was a worthy attempt, but too hamstrung by a lack of sympathy and a willingness to indulge in straw-manning to really grasp the nettle either of their beliefs and goals or of the disagreement between them and others (including the author).
I try to read everything Paul Sloan writes, esp. about Pauline or other NT writings about Torah. This week I caught up on articles from 2023 and 2025. Self-recommending.
In “All About Love,” bell hooks argues that “we would all love better if we used it as a verb” instead of a noun. In our loving relationships, she writes, the “choice must be made to nurture growth.” This idea finds shape in the romantic interactivity of Grand Theft Auto VI, where players must actively choose closeness and intimacy.
From the NYT review, presented without comment.
Whether or not Wemby ever wins MVP—this or any season—it is incredible that, in the last thirty years and change, the Spurs have had a claim to featuring the best player in the league at that particular moment: David Robinson (1995), Tim Duncan (2001–5), Kawhi Leonard (2015–17), and Victor Wembanyama (2026–).
Read Andrew Hendrixson on art as a means of disclosure. Come for the opening vignette, stay for the final line.
He comes across as another Kevin Durant: lonely and melancholy in his earnest demand for respect, yet caught in a feedback loop that eventually terminates in isolation and resentment. Let’s hope Philly changes that.
Read Dan Chiasson’s 2007 New Yorker profile of Les Murray, including this late line:
Because, like all mature poets, Murray knows and represents his own imaginative limitations, his best poems show empathy lagging a little behind the imagination.
Read Daniel K. Williams on the past, present, and future of Christianity Today.
The late Clive James on the late Les Murray:
[His] Collected Poems is a book precious beyond all prizes: one of the great books of our contemporary world. The proliferation of its inventiveness finally makes irrelevant the question of why he does not write in forms: everything he writes has a form of its own.
Like the monuments to every
mortal thing that a planet without God
would require, and inscriptionless
as rage would soon weather those,
the anthills erupt on verges,
on streets, round the glaring pub,
its mango trees and sleeping-fridges,
an estuary of undergrounds,
dried cities of the flying worm.
—Les Murray, final stanza of “Contested Landscape at Forsayth,” collected in Subhuman Redneck Poems (1996)
Unfermented grape juice is a bland and pleasant drink, especially on a warm afternoon mixed half-and-half with ginger ale. It is a ghastly symbol of the life blood of Jesus Christ, especially when served in individual antiseptic, thimble-sized glasses.
Wine is booze, which means it is dangerous and drunk-making. It makes the timid brave and the reserved amorous. It loosens the tongue and breaks the ice, especially when served in a loving cup. It kills germs. As symbols go, it is a rather splendid one.
—Frederick Buechner, Wishful Thinking: A Seeker’s ABC, p. 120
Humans are so the universe will have something to talk through, so God will have something to talk with, and so the rest of us will have something to talk about.
—Frederick Buechner, Wishful Thinking: A Seeker’s ABC, p. 47
Had never before read this 2009 essay by Michael Spencer predicting “the coming evangelical collapse."
What’s interesting about all such prophecies is the way that the predictive/descriptive and the normative/axiological get entwined. Best to disentangle them. E.g., evangelicalism could become a horror show and simultaneously popular; or apolitical and decline; or orthodox and stagnate; or heretical and entertainment-focused and become the largest religious blog in the nation. Quality and quantity are not the same thing; fidelity and success do not go hand in hand (and the same is true for unfaithfulness and failure).
Notes for a future essay…
Dale Coulter again: I will now be using “split-screen Protestantism” in all my reflection and writing on American evangelicalism.
I thought Ronald Dworkin’s essay on Illich and medicine was thoughtful, fair, and critical in all the right places. This paragraph especially was a useful sympathetic summary:
Illich went beyond simple conspiracy theories to explain these events. It was more than just doctors or pharmaceutical companies pushing medicines to make money, he said, although that was part of it. More important, he suggested, was an iron triangle of support for the new approach: a public that wanted the quickest and surest route to happiness (“unrealistic expectations on the part of patient majorities”), doctors aspiring to manage everyday unhappiness scientifically—as if unhappiness were an engineering problem—and pharmaceutical companies eager to meet the new demand while putting their fingers on the scale when regulators tested their products.
Followed by this long paragraph:
Here is one application of Marx’s ideas to contemporary American health that follows Illich’s approach. A growing population needs more food. The market produces mass quantities of cheap, highly processed food to satisfy the need. This leads to more cases of obesity, type 2 diabetes, and high cholesterol. The market invents diabetes and high-cholesterol medications to meet these new needs, tying patients closer to medicine. Persistent obesity also leads to low self-esteem and depression among the population. To meet these needs the market invents diet food and regimens, as well as therapists and counselors to attack the problem of low self-esteem directly. But crash diets and diet food often make people hungrier and cause even more weight gain. Meanwhile, therapists and counselors—whose services allow people to shed friends and family as confidants—can be expensive. Inevitably, more new needs arise. The market addresses the need for more urgent weight loss through Ozempic-like medications; for cheaper self-esteem through antidepressants; for cheaper companionship and counseling through telehealth and chatbots. Patients are tied even more closely to market solutions and professional medicine. Yet these solutions, of course, create new problems, such as “Ozempic face” stemming from rapid fat loss, and therefore new needs. The market comes to the rescue with new plastic surgeries for repair, including new dermal fillers to return volume to people’s faces—and the dialectical cycle goes on and on. Illich deserves credit for applying early Marxian ideas to the medical profession. He didn’t invent the intellectual paradigm, but he applied it in an original and insightful way to diagnose new problems.
And, truth be told, while I am temperamentally and intellectually a man of the old Christian-socialistic “left”, and think healthcare should be available to everyone, wealth should be fairly distributed, and society should be as charitably pluralistic as possible, I am not an American liberal or much of a bien pensant, and I am simply too damned old now to respond to the sight of preferred pronouns in parentheses after someone’s name with anything other than an arched brow of mystification. (“Why does he/she imagine,” I find myself wondering, “that I will ever be talking about him/her in the third person?”)
That’s DBH, who still has his fastball.
The best election postmortem is still Caldwell’s.
And while all the infighting and gloating will continue for some time, MBD’s analysis of the next 2-3 years on the right is worth considering.
Not doing his homework, Bishop Saenz stopped dialoguing and started litigating. I have seen bishops make this mistake before when dealing with large congregations. They act like it’s the mid-twentieth century, when Protestant denominations were strong and episcopal authority was absolute, rather than recognizing the postdenominational world of the twenty-first century.
Bracing words from Dale Coulter, whose newsletter is, at the moment, the very best source for charting “the postdenominational world of the twenty-first century," not least its Pentecostal-charismatic/multiracial/informal-networking character.
More (now from Michael Pina) on the Spurs' three-guard / one alien starting lineup.
Timothy Burke has always sounded like a model teacher, and here he is showing why.
Read Adam Roberts on Tolkien, LOTR, and curiositas. Including this little kicker:
This line of thought, indeed, leads me to wonder about the ways we fans have, in effect, failed Tolkien’s test. Temptation exists in the world for us to measure our powers of resistance against. Boromir, for example, is led astray by his pride and fails the test the ring represents. But the novel itself embodies a manifest temptation to a particular sort of fan: it gives us glimpses, in song and allusion, to a deep past lying behind the story’s now. It teases us with bits and pieces in imaginary languages. We could, if we chose, simply take those things as they are offered, and enjoy the affect (let’s say: awe, wonder, whatever the opposite of vertigo is) they generate in us. But we don’t. We are overwhelmed by our curiosity, and become positively Sarumanic in our eagerness to winkle out all the myriad trivial details of that past, constructing for ourselves elaborate textual machines to that effect.
Douthat is self-recommending, but I especially enjoyed his pieces on evangelicalism and the robot apocalypse.